рус eng
«IZVESTIYA IRKUTSKOGO GOSUDARSTVENNOGO UNIVERSITETA». SERIYA «POLITOLOGIYA. RELIGIOVEDENIE»
«THE BULLETIN OF IRKUTSK STATE UNIVERSITY». SERIES «POLITICAL SCIENCE AND RELIGION STUDIES»
ISSN 2073-3380 (Print)

List of issues > Series «Political Science and Religion Studies». 2023. Vol 44

The Experience of a Systematic Exposure of Methodology Mental Studies

Author(s)
N. M. Rakityanskiy
Abstract
The publication discusses the foundations of the methodological model that was used in the preparation of the monograph “Mental studies of global political worlds” [41]. The text contains three main relatively independent sections. In the first one, the author presents his understanding of the phenomenon of mentality and the methodological model of its political and psychological research. Here we are talking about the content and internal organization of the mental research model, the principles of its construction, functions and methodological resource. The second paragraph reveals the heuristic potential of the dogmatic principle, its methodological and ontological significance. The last part is devoted to identifying the historical foundations of the phenomenon of subjectivity and the concept of the fundamental subjective triad. Summarizing, the author formulates the thesis that the methodological basis for the study of the mentality of political worlds is the trinity of the principle of historicism, the dogmatic principle and the principle of subjectivity.
About the Authors
Rakityanskiy Nikolay Mitrofanovich, Doctor of Sciences (Psychology), Professor, Department of Sociology and Psychology of Politics, Lomonosov Moscow State University, 1, Leninskie Gory, Moscow, 119991, Russian Federation, e-mail: drkayros@yandex.ru
For citation
Rakityansky N.M. The Experience of a Systematic Exposure of Methodology Mental Studies. The Bulletin of Irkutsk State University. Series Political Science and Religion Studies, 2023, vol. 44, pp. 30–49. https://doi.org/10.26516/2073- 3380.2023.44.30 (in Russian)
Keywords
methodology, mentality, mentalization, dogma, dogmatic principle, subjectivity, non-subjectivity, subjective principle, consciousness, superconsciousness, identity.
UDC
159.9
DOI
https://doi.org/10.26516/2073-3380.2023.44.30
References
  1. Abulkhanova K.A. Printsip subjekta v otechestvennoy psikhologii [The principle of the subject in domestic psychology]. Psychology. Journal of the Higher School of Economics, 2005, vol. 2, no. 4, pр. 3-21. (in Russian)
  2. Averintsev S.S. Poetika rannevizantiyskoy literatura [Poetics of Early Byzantine Literature]. Moscow, Coda Publ., 1977, 343 р. (in Russian)
  3. Aleksandrov Yu.I., Kirdina S.G. Tipy mentalnosti i institutsionalnye matritsy: multidistsiplinarnyy podkhod [Types of mentality and institutional matrices: a multidisciplinary approach]. Sociologicheskie issledovaniya [Sociological research], 2012, no. 8, pр. 3-12. (in Russian)
  4. Ananiev B.G. Chelovek kak predmet poznaniya [Man as an object of knowledge]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 2000, 288 р. (in Russian)
  5. Bakhtin M.M. K filosofii postupka. Raboty 20-kh godov [To the philosophy of the act. Works of the 20s.]. Kiеv, Next Publ., 1994, 383 р. (in Russian)
  6. Berdyaev N.A. Smysl istorii [The meaning of history]. Moscow, Thought Publ., 1990, 175 р.(in Russian)
  7. Berdyaev N.A. Filosofiya svobodnogo dukha [Philosophy of the free spirit]. Moscow, Respublika Publ., 1994, 480 р. (in Russian)
  8. Berdyaev N.A. Filosofiya svobody. Sochineniya [Philosophy of freedom]. Moscow, 1994, 608 р. (in Russian)
  9. Bogdanova O.A. Problema vzaimodeystviya khristianskikh konfessiy i gosudarstva v sovremennom mire: komparativistskiy analiz [The problem of interaction between Christian denominations and the state in the modern world: a comparative analysis]. Nauchnaya mysl Kavkaza [Scientific Thought of the Caucasus], 2019, no. 3 (99), pр. 49-55. (in Russian)
  10. Buber M. Izbrannye proizvedeniya [Selected works]. Per. from German N. Bartman, A. Ginzai, F. Gurfinkel. Selected works. Printed in Israel. Library-Alia, 1979, 357 р. (in Russian)
  11. Bulgakov S.N. Dva grada [Two cities]. Moscow, 2008, 410 р. (in Russian)
  12. Bacon F. O dostoinstve i priumnozhenii nauk [On the dignity and multiplication of sciences]. Sochineniya. In 2 vol. Vol. 1. Moscow, Thought Publ., 1971, 590 р. (in Russian)
  13. Wallerstein I. Analiz mirovykh sistem i situatsiya v sovremennom mire [Analysis of world systems and the situation in the modern world]. Transl. from English. St. Petersburg, Universitetskaya kniga Publ., 2001, 416 р. (in Russian)
  14. Vernadsky V.I. O nauchnom mirovozzrenii [On the scientific worldview] Izbr. works on the history of science. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1981, 336 р. (in Russian)
  15. Vygotsky L.S. Sobranie sochineniy. V 6 t. T. 3. Problemy razvitiya psikhiki [Collected works: In 6 vol. T.Z. Problems of the development of the psyche]. Ed. A.M. Matyushkin. Moscow, Pedagogy Publ., 1983, 368 р. (in Russian)
  16. Dmitrieva Yu.A., Gryazeva-Dobshinskaya V.G. Metod modelirovaniya v sotsialnoy psikhologii [Modeling method in social psychology]. Socialnaya psihologiya [Social psychology], 2013, vol. 6, no. 1, pр. 18-26. (in Russian)
  17. Egorov V.V. Naglyadnye obrazy v formirovanii mentaliteta obshchestva [Visual images in the formation of the mentality of society]. Cand. sci. diss. abstr. Ekaterinburg, 2003. 48 р. (in Russian)
  18. Zadorozhnyuk I.E. Grazhdanskaya religiya v SShA: sotsialno-filosofskiy analiz [Civil religion in the USA: socio-philosophical analysis]. Cand. sci. diss. abstr. Moscow, 2008, 46 р. (in Russian)
  19. Zelinsky A.N. Ideya kosmosa v buddiyskoy mysli [The idea of space in Buddhist thought]. Countries and peoples of the East. Iss. 15. Asia and Africa. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1973, pр. 322-339. (in Russian)
  20. Kaluzhskaya E.V. Religioznoe sektantstvo kak fenomen postmoderna [Religious sectarianism as a postmodern phenomenon]. Socialnaya politika i sociologiya [Social policy and sociology], 2009, no. 1, pр. 224-234. (in Russian)
  21. Kanterov I.Ya. Novye religioznye dvizheniya. Enciklopediya religij [New religious movements. Encyclopedia of Religions.]. Moscow, Academic project Publ., 2008, 472 р. (in Russian)
  22. Karpov A.V. Psikhologiya refleksivnykh mekhanizmov deyatelnosti [Psychology of reflexive mechanisms of activity]. Moscow, Institute of Psychology of the Russian Academy of Sciences Publ., 2004, 424 р. (in Russian)
  23. Kosichenko A.G. Globalizatsiya i religiya [Globalization and Religion]. Vek globalizacii [Age of Globalization], 2013, no. 1, pр. 47-48. (in Russian)
  24. Kutyrev V.A. Kultura i tekhnologiya: borba mirov [Culture and Technology: The Struggle of the Worlds]. Moscow, Progress-Tradition Publ., 2001, 240 р. (in Russian)
  25. Legeev M., Zinkovsky S., Zinkovsky E. Ekumenizm kak yavlenie sovremennosti [Ecumenism as a phenomenon of modernity]. Vestnik Russkoj hristianskoj gumanitarnoj akademii [Bulletin of the Russian Christian Academy for the Humanities], 2017, vol. 18, iss. 4, pр. 223-240. (in Russian)
  26. Lektorsky V.A., Oizerman T.I. Teoriya poznaniya. T. 3. Poznanie kak istoricheskiy protsess[Theory of knowledge. Vol. 3. Cognition as a historical process]. Moscow, Thought Publ., 1993, 397 р. (in Russian)
  27. Lektorsky V.A., Shvyrev V.S. Metodologicheskiy analiz nauki [Methodological analysis of science]. Filosofija, metodologija, nauka [Philosophy, methodology, science]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1972, pр. 7-44. (in Russian)
  28. Leontiev A.N. Deyatelnost. Soznanie. Lichnost [Activity. Consciousness. Personality]. Moscow, Politizdat Publ., 1975, 304 р. (in Russian)
  29. Losev A.F. Dialektika mifa [Dialectic of myth]. Moscow, Akademicheskiy Proekt Publ., 2008, 303 р. (in Russian)
  30. Losev A.F. Mif, chislo, sushchnost [Myth, number, essence]. Moscow, Thought Publ., 1994, 920 р. (in Russian)
  31. Losev A.F. Uchenie o stile [Teaching about style]. Moscow, St. Petersburg, Nestor-Istoriya Publ., 2019, 456 р. (in Russian)
  32. Medvedev V.A. Parametry metodologicheskoy sostavlyayushchey poznavatelnogo protsessa [Parameters of the methodological component of the cognitive process]. Nauchnij ezhegodnik Instituta filosofii i prava Uralskogo otdelenija Rossijskoj akademii nauk [Scientific Yearbook of the Institute of Philosophy and Law of the Ural Branch of the Russian Academy of Sciences], 2010, no. 10, рр. 23-34. (in Russian)
  33. Mozharovsky V.V. Kritika dogmaticheskogo myshleniya i analiz religiozno-mentalnykh osnovaniy politiki [Criticism of dogmatic thinking and analysis of the religious-mental foundations of politics]. St Petersburg, Ovizo Publ., 2002, 272 р. (in Russian)
  34. Moren E. O slozhnostnosti [About complexity]. Moscow, Institute for General Humanitarian Research Publ., 2019, 284 р. (in Russian)
  35. Nikolaeva T.M. O chem rasskazyvayut nam teksty? [What do the texts tell us?]. Moscow, Yazyki slavyanskikh kultur Publ., 2012, 328 р. (in Russian)
  36. Noss I.N., Kovaleva M.E. Modelirovanie v psikhologicheskom issledovanii [Modeling in psychological research]. Teoreticheskaja i eksperimentalnaja psihologija [Theoretical and experimental psychology], 2019, vol. 12, no. 2, рр. 63-69. (in Russian)
  37. Petukhov A.Yu. Modelirovanie sotsialnykh i politicheskikh protsessov [Modeling of social and political processes]. Nizhny Novgorod, NNGU im. N.I. Lobachevskogo Publ., 2015, 141 р. (in Russian)
  38. Pico della Mirandola J. Rech o dostoinstve cheloveka [Speech on the dignity of man]. Antologija filosofii Srednih vekov i epohi Vozrozhdenija [Anthology of Philosophy of the Middle Ages and the Renaissance]. Comp. S.V. Perevezentsev. Moscow, OLMA-press Publ., 2001, pр. 13-17. (in Russian)
  39. Polomoshnov P.A. Problema lichnosti v islame [The problem of personality in Islam]. Islamovedenie [Islamic Studies], 2015, vol. 6, no. 4 (26), pр. 78-88. (in Russian)
  40. Rakityansky N.M. Iudeyskiy mentalitet. Politiko-psikhologicheskoe esse [Jewish mentality. Political and psychological essay]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta [Bulletin of Moscow University Ser. 12], 2013, no. 4, pр. 55-81. (in Russian)
  41. Rakityansky N.M. Mentalnye issledovanija globalnyh politicheskih mirov [Mental studies of global political worlds]. Moscow, Moscow University Press Publ., 2020, 464 р. (in Russian)
  42. Rakityansky N.M. Opyt konceptualnogo analiza islamskogo mentaliteta v kontekste politicheskoj psihologii [The experience of conceptual analysis of the Islamic mentality in the context of political psychology]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta [Bulletin of the Moscow University. Series 12. Political sciences], 2012, no. 5, pр. 53-71. (in Russian)
  43. Rakityansky N.M. Fenomen i koncept sverhsoznanija v politicheskoj psihologii [Phenomenon and concept of superconsciousness in political psychology]. Mir i politika [World and Politics], 2013, no. 6, pр. 236-245. (in Russian)
  44. Rakityansky N.M., Sun Ts. Opyt konceptualnogo modelirovanija kitajskogo politicheskogo mentaliteta. Chast 1 [Experience of conceptual modeling of the Chinese political mentality. Part 1]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 12 [Bulletin of the Moscow University. Series 12. Political sciences], 2016, no. 2, pр. 57-79. (in Russian)
  45. Rakityansky N.M., Sun Ts. Opyt konceptualnogo modelirovanija kitajskogo politicheskogo mentaliteta. Chast 2 [Experience of conceptual modeling of the Chinese political mentality. Part 2]. Vestnik Moskovskogo universiteta. Ser. 12. [Bulletin of the Moscow University. Series 12. Political sciences], 2016, no. 5, pр. 64-86. (in Russian)
  46. Rats M.V. Metodologija: mladshaja sestra nauki ili ee mat? [Methodology: the younger sister of science or her mother?]. Nezavisimaja gazeta. Nauka [Independent newspaper. The science], 2004, no. 3 (76).
  47. Rozov N.S. Dinamicheskaja koncepcija mentaliteta i izmenchivoe raznoobrazie rossijskih gabitusov [Dynamic Concept of Mentality and Variable Diversity of Russian Habitus]. Idei i idealy [Ideas and Ideals]. 2010, vol. 1, no. 1(3), pр. 60-79. (in Russian)
  48. Rubanov V.A. Vizhu smysl. Metafizika smyslov. T. 1 [I see the point. Metaphysics of meanings. Vol. 1]. Moscow, Argo-Kniga Publ., 2022, 365 р. (in Russian)
  49. Rubinstein S.L. Bytie i soznanie. O meste psihicheskogo vo vseobshhej vzaimosvjazi javlenij materialnogo mira [Being and consciousness. On the place of the psychic in the general interconnection of the phenomena of the material world]. Moscow, AN SSSR Publ., 1957, 328 р. (in Russian)
  50. Sondi L. Sudboanaliz : statii [Fate analysis: Articles]. Per. with him. A.V. Tikhomirov. Moscow, Three squares Publ., 2007, 480 р. (in Russian)
  51. Teilhard de Chardin P. Fenomen cheloveka [The phenomenon of man]. Moscow, Nauka Publ., 1987, 239 р. (in Russian)
  52. Trendelenburg A. Jelementy logiki Aristotelja [Elements of Aristotle's logic]. Per. B.A. Fokht, A.G. Vashestov. Moscow, Canon + ROOI “Rehabilitation” Publ., 2017, 336 р. (in Russian)
  53. Ukhtomsky A.A. Dominanta [Dominant]. Moscow, Public Domain Publ., 2019, 258 р. (in Russian)
  54. Flier A.Ya. Ocherki teorii istoricheskoj dinamiki kultury. Monografija [Essays on the theory of the historical dynamics of culture. Monograph. Electronic edition]. Moscow, Consent Publ., 2015. URL: https://studref.com/536723/kulturologiya/evolyutsiya_dominantnyh_ identichnostey (in Russian)
  55. Huntington S. Stolknovenie civilizacij [Clash of Civilizations]. Moscow, AST Publ., 1996, 640 р. (in Russian)
  56. Horafas D.N. Sistemy i modelirovanie [Systems and modeling]. Per. from English. ed. I.N. Kovalenko. Moscow, Mir Publ., 1967, 419 р. (in Russian)
  57. Chelpanov G.I. Mozg i dusha: kritika materializma i ocherk sovremennyh uchenij o dushe [Brain and Soul: A Critique of Materialism and an Outline of Contemporary Teachings on the Soul]. Kyiv, 1906, 319 р. (in Russian)
  58. Shestov L. Afiny i Ierusalim [Athens and Jerusalem]. Moscow, AST Publ., 2007, 414 р. (in Russian)
  59. Shpet G.G. Soznanie i ego sobstvennik [Consciousness and its owner]. Georgiju Ivanovichu Chelpanovu ot uchastnikov ego seminariev v Kyive i Moskve 1891–1916. Statii po filosofii i psihologii [Georgy Ivanovich Chelpanov from the participants of his seminaries in Kyiv and Moscow 1891-1916. Articles on philosophy and psychology]. Moscow, 1916, pр. 156-210. (in Russian)
  60. Shpet G.G. Javlenie i smysl. Fenomenologija kak osnovnaja nauka i ee problemy [Appearance and meaning. Phenomenology as a basic science and its problems]. Selected works. Moscow, ROSSPEN Publ., 2010, рp. 524-536. (in Russian)
  61. Egilsky E.E., Matetskaya A.V., Samygin S.I. Novye religioznye dvizhenija. Sovremennye netradicionnye religii i jezotericheskie uchenija: uchebnoe posobie [New religious movements. Modern non-traditional religions and esoteric teachings: textbook]. Moscow, Knorus Publ., 2011, 224 р. (in Russian)
  62. Yuriev A.I. Predislovie [Foreword]. Rakitjanskij N. M. Mentalnye issledovanija globalnyh politicheskih mirov [Rakityansky N.M. Mental studies of global political worlds]. Moscow, Mosk. unt Publ., 2020, pp. 19-20. (in Russian)
  63. Becchio B., Schadé J.P. Encyclopedia of World Religions. 2006. 960 р. URL: https://books.google.ru/books?id=130GngEACAAJ&printsec=frontcover&hl=ru#v=onepage&q&f=false
  64. Modern Paganism in World Cultures. Comparative Perspectives / Edited by Michael F. Strmiska. Santa Barbara, California Denver, Colorado Oxford, England, 2005, 398 р.
  65. Morin E. Antidote pour les pensées uniques Entretien avec Edgar Morin. URL: https://gerflint.fr/Base/Roumanie3/nelson.pdf

Full text (russian)